Actually going back to week one and matching every coin to the information on the charts, which is public record, you can see that a lot of money has been made. I'll give them that
On my first week with them I made money on my first trade, so clearly some disconnect in some of the stories being told
Well, I took an example earlier, based on the January 5 internal PM sent to members. They did on average 42% profit, IF they ideally bought and sold at the right time. What percentage do you think Ryan is going to brag about? 500% 1000%?
I am very sure that you have made money on some or most trades, which is a good thing. But you see some people are, or might be, unhappy with their results versus the payment they made.
Say if someone pays 0.5 BTC for the service and invests 1 BTC in the 4 picks given on Jan 5th, and their wallet shows 1.42 BTC (at best), then they are at a loss. I'm not saying that it doesn't work, or that Ryan gets free money for not providing anything of value, his ideas are pretty good, except the one where he claims 1000% results when there is only 42%, and the one where he uses directly or indirectly many forum accounts to lash out at critiques. You can see everywhere people getting taken advantage off, I have to fight off poor oblivious redditors that still believe Paycoin is a good thing and the CEO is a super-smart-nice guy...
If your users get the service in the advertised parameters, then any idiot that comments against you should shut the hell up. Make me that idiot, show me that your service delivers, let's see the sums.