I have a question, is someone with the card number and PIN able to cancel an order? For example would it have been possible for the OP to cancel the order then quickly place another order since he knew the card number?
It would probably be possible if they called into customer service. The activity on the codes shows that they were used once and the order was cancelled, and the balances were not credited back. At this point it's just rail birds commenting on the situation that haven't fully read the thread or know the situation.
I saw that you posted a picture where you received an email that says "you" canceled (I believe it has been established that this is just a template) the order, however is there additional information in the email that potentially has more information about that order that can be linked to the cards? For example an order number....
Here's all the proof -
http://imgur.com/de5Q9sWhttp://imgur.com/XA8zJJIhttp://imgur.com/KKpjUpKOkay, so from that it looks like I can say the following:
1 - Order number sbx22043943 was canceled.
2 - The 5 gift cards all have a $0 balance on them today
3 - The 5 gift cards all had a $100 balance on them when they were given to you
4 - The 5 gift cards all have a redeem transaction on the 26th of January
5 - None of the 5 gift cards ever had any balance put back on them
Do you have anything to tie order number sbx22043943 to the 5 gift cards? (I may have mistyped the order from looking at the picture). Maybe a confirmation email when you placed the order (with your shipping addressed redacted)?
In the pictures I just provided you can cross reference the last four digits of each card number applied to the order to the card numbers that James sent me via PM on Bitcointalk.