Because Nubbins, self proclaimed "scambuster" decided unilaterally that he could not have possibly carved any of his pieces by hand and started a mob which proceeded to attack WC based on those accusations and speculation alone, with no evidence of wrong doing and all of his actual customers satisfied. It basically boils down to drama seeking behavior and an attempt to slander his reputation. I have traded with WC and he delivered what was promised. If you are still unsure, escrow is available with OGNasty.