you already admitted monero had at least a 2.5% (total coin supply) instamined or "unfair" mining issues.
I did not admit that Monero has any instamine, because it does not.
so i guess you agree cmc should add 3 *** for the "unfair mining" of monero?
It is up to them if they want to start rating the "fairness" of mining, as opposed to the more objective question of whether there is a large discontinuity of supply at launch (significant premine or instamine). That's not something they've done so far.
It is only an "anti-dash site" as you call it in that the author did a huge amount of work to carefully evaluate a large number of coins (shown on the right hand column) and one of several that was evaluated negatively on the basis of a clear instamine was dash (then called darkcoin).