Then you should have read Matt's rules before betting with Matt in Matt's thread. Too late now, you're in.
I'm not saying there's wiggle room, and I'm not saying there should be wiggle room, but if Theymos is really going to be distributing scammer tags, the real questions are these:
1) Who does Theymos think won the bet
2) Is Theymos biased now that he has money on the line
3) Does 2 matter in bitcoinland
To be sure I don't piss off a mod for no good reason, let me add to clarify that (3) is not about Theymos or even this forum. I recently made a similar post about such concern with GLBSE and OBSI.HRPT. See here:
...
My point being in both cases that we are in the wild wild west, not that anyone is abusing power.