It started because they were taking investors. However, they've closed that program now so it would seem that everyone has had their say here already and we should probably just see what happens. Several folks have expressed the skepticism that because they refuse to show their funds, they may not actually have them. However, dadice has stated that he's not going to bow down and do exactly what people tell him to do just because they demand it. I can see both sides having merit. I also don't like being told what to do.
Dadice has been growing and working well, they aren't going to prove their bankroll. I think that's what this all adds up to.
I have a question for OP Shorena: if, say, dadice continues to go along with no problems, how long will you let your negative feedback stand. You admit that your feedback is speculative, I'm just curious about how long you think it should stand if things continue to go smoothly for them.
Their unwillingness
to do the right thing and demonstrate their solvency is a warning sign that needs to be flagged. They way they reacted to the community requesting proof of solvency is another red flag. Nobody is telling them what to do. Rather, we are warning potential customers who might otherwise be unaware of DaDice's actions.
I think you need to change "do the right thing" to "do what we say is the right thing". Presumably they don't agree that doing what you say is the right thing. Anyway, I'm not suggesting that you guys remove your negative feedback now, I'm suggesting that at some point in the future, if things continue to go fine with dadice (they offer their service, people use it, can withdrawl as needed) then it would seem that you'd admit that your warnings were unfounded and you'd remove the negative feedback. You'd say, "well they never proved their solvency to me but I guess they didn't really have to do that and it's been X (days/months/years/centuries) now and I guess I can safely remove this warning. " If that's right, I'm curious how long you think the warning should stand. What's the right value and unit for X?