So far we have honored each and every withdrawal request.
That is what every scammer says while they're in the "building trust" phase of the scam.
Try going to any Ponzi scam thread and warning that it is a scam. Their first defence is always "but we are paying"...
To fair, it's also exactly what every honest person says who pays and plans to continue to pay. It's not logical to act like pointing to a solid reputation is an indicator of guilt.
To be honest, I think that the fair, well-meaning advice for everyone to caveat emptor when dealing with dadice was quite fair. But I think turning that into a continual harping, and now trolling is pretty shameful.