Well this is just a theory, but there is nothing wrong with discussing it (I will not comment it though).
The block size debate is about taking over control. It's about either putting the trust into the hands of the Core developers or Gavin and Hearn. The question is who do you trust?
And that is the major problem. We should not have to place our trust in anybody when it comes to bitcoin or at least that is how I feel about it. The main thing about bitcoin which convinced me to get involved in the first place was the fact that you could be your own bank and the fact that it operated in a trustless and decentralised manner.