So what you are implying is that if/when a new digital currency overtakes Bitcoin, it will be one that thrives off of a different community altogether?

That's.... actually a plausible occurrance, and one I haven't even thought of before. I would definitely agree that the anarcho beliefs of the early adopters are a bit too extreme to be a good foundation for a universal currency, and I suppose if something was birthed in the perfect environment it could become vastly more popular (and therefore superior in value) to Bitcoin.