I guess the conclusion of this thread is that the server seed that unibtc was playing with was lost, which means it was either done intentionally to hide the fact some of his rolls were rigged to win back the money ... or done as a silly mistake.
In reality it is quite easy to tell
magicdice please generate a chart of the player profits during the time before the server seedIf the end of the chart shows the player winning money then magicdice obviously wasn't cheating but would explain why magicdice was scared the player was cheating and justifies them changing the server seed incorrectly
If the end of the chart shows the player losing money then magicdice cheated the player with fake rolls and covered their tracks by losing the server seed. They would have had no reason to be scared the player was cheating and need to change the server seed