I have tried 3 different power strips. What is odd is the short is not causing the GFCI on the outlet to pop.
I should not assume but you are using on a US outlet right? Not somewhere where adapter is needed?
I'm going to guess US. But your on right track on contacting seller. I would love to tell you to open it up and see if something is off, but that no doubt would make it where seller would make you keep it.