Post
Topic
Board Development & Technical Discussion
Re: Increasing the blocksize as a (generalized) softfork.
by
ZoomT
on 20/12/2015, 16:38:02 UTC
1) You are proposing to fork the blockchain without consensus.

A generalized softfork has the same minimum requirements of a standard softfork, i.e. >50% of mining hashpower.  In practice it would wiser to shoot for something beyond the bare minimum, such as the standard 75% or 95% of hash power as with other forks.  The point is that this proposal is no different than other softforks in terms of requirements.

Quote
2) Your generalized soft fork idea breaks one of the basic principles of Bitcoin, storing all of the transaction history in the blockchain.

This proposal is an alternative to hardforks which completely replace the blockchain with a new version under different rules.  My proposal does exactly the same thing, but does so essentially as a softfork.  The new chain keeps all the the transaction history on the chain under the new rules.