Post
Topic
Board Development & Technical Discussion
Re: Who is phantomcircuit, and is this OK ?
by
Luke-Jr
on 15/11/2012, 21:41:46 UTC
Saw this on #bitcoin-dev IRC chat today:

Quote
07:59   phantomcircuit   jgarzik, i actually have code to ddos the entire network
07:59   phantomcircuit   it works
07:59   phantomcircuit   but i run out of local port numbers before i get past about 100 peers

If I found a DoS vulnerability I wouldn't brag about it in public-- I'd tell the developers privately.

And isn't testing a DoS on a production network immoral/illegal ?
You cut off the end:
Quote
[Thursday, November 15, 2012] [7:59:29 AM]    jgarzik, i actually have code to ddos the entire network
[Thursday, November 15, 2012] [7:59:31 AM]    it works
[Thursday, November 15, 2012] [7:59:44 AM]    but i run out of local port numbers before i get past about 100 peers
[Thursday, November 15, 2012] [7:59:44 AM]    um
[Thursday, November 15, 2012] [7:59:45 AM]    :(
[Thursday, November 15, 2012] [7:59:55 AM]    you can't know it works without having DDoS'd the network -.-
[Thursday, November 15, 2012] [8:00:44 AM]    Luke-Jr, well it worked against the roughly dozen bitcoin nodes i run
[Thursday, November 15, 2012] [8:00:52 AM]    scale to all connectable peers
In other words, he tested this on his own nodes.

I presume if there was anything we could do to fix it, he'd have mentioned that in private.