The idea of enabling nodes & miners to set a market block-size is quite reasonable so there is no criticism of the idea.
That seems a reasonable result. Just need to iron out the details....
In summary:
1. The use case: dynamic market set block-sizes are interesting.
2. bitcoin unlimited proposals so far seems broken as discussed by multiple people for a whole range of reasons. We didnt have a crisp definition and it seems that some things maybe undecided. That's ok - just keep working on it and make a concrete proposal later and people can analyse it from that.
I wouldn't say they are 'broken' - there is a lot of misunderstanding about it, and due to the level of censure taking place on bitcointalk its difficult to get a clear picture of what it is about on this forum.
So may I respectfully point interested parties to the BU 'white paper' ( without having this post moderated/deleted as a result)
here where you can digest the finer details. Additionally, the
FAQ provides a higher level description of key topics. This should remove some of the guesswork which has characterised this thread. Then present your thoughts or arguments on the unmoderated /r/btc reddit or directly to bitco.in where they can be discussed.