Well I agreed with Fuseleer that Partitions can be created, but this doesn't change the problem that consensus still needs to be attained within each Partition and a global consensus is still needed for those who wish to spend to another partition; and consensus will always require PoW or PoS. So afaics you haven't disagreed with what I wrote.
Did I miss your point?
You can still obey CAP and produce a viable, decentralised cryptocurrency IMO. Losing partition tolerance is the lesser of three evils, but like I say, how can you agree with someone you've never spoken to?