The total supply of bitcoin will continue to increase, it will just increase slower than before. This will only result in an increase in value if an increase in demand outpaces the increase in supply. It is possible that the value will increase in the future, but it is also possible that the value has already increased in expectation of the reduction in block reward and that a slower increase in demand causes the value to drop. The future can be difficult to predict reliably.
Wouldn't the halving of the money supply cause doubling of value of each coin though?