A few updates-
I tried using LibertyX. When I went to the store to get my PIN, I was told they don't do it anymore because the state (CA) put a 20% tax on these transactions. I contacted LibertyX for clarification. They deleted that location (the most popular in my area) and said to try somewhere else. Not very reassuring.
Next I tried BitQuick. I went to bank (Chase) and was told I cannot deposit cash into another person's account if I do not have an account there. BitQuick support says they are wrong and I should try another bank.
Cryptonit posted above and suggested I try them. I submitted my verification this morning. I received a reply on the site's message system but can no longer get in. The site does not recognize my pw and the reset page is currently non-functional.
I need to follow up with the exchanges i sent verification.
Use Wall of Coins:
https://wallofcoins.comIt's true about Chase---their tellers don't even know their own policies. However, most likely the account you tried to deposit into had a warning: "Possible Scam Account". No one will let you deposit into an account flagged like this. It doesn't surprise me that a seller using bitquick (not-so quick) has their account flagged as a possible scam account....
I have used Wall of coins before and I have to say it is good. It connects the seller and buyer very nicely and I have not seen someone rate it bad.
Never tried BitQuick but I agree the account was probably flagged.