It's fundamentalism that's moronic, independently of the flavor 
Amen! Thanks, I've been itching to use one of these...
Your logical fallacy is...
I didn't offer a compromize, I stated a fact.
Fundamentalism is a distinct process and there is not middle ground between differnt kinds of fundamentalism. Fundamentalism always leads to tyranny and it is fueld by ignorance not by rigorousity.
Then your comment is significantly off-topic. I took it to mean that either of the two extremes presented here was a poor choice, and that the answer lies somewhere in the middle. But I agree, that fundamentalism, fueled by ignorance does indeed always lead to tyranny.