I actually had a similar idea. I think whoever buys the company should give the people that have money on the site Cryptsy shares (shares of the company) equivalent to what they lost. Then they could set up the shares to trade on the site like the other coins.
Why would anybody buy the company? No assets, no brand value, and a CEO on the lam.
The only way I can think of is that they absorb their debt and build a new company. This will definitely makes them instantly trust worthy but of course, it's a very risky move.