Ok so pirateat40 has been seen in person, before he was labeled scammer. But I still don't see his confirmed name and address anywhere, can you point that out to me?
Learn to use the search tool.

Also, even if someone was able to put the pieces together and confirm his name and address, this is still quite different from BFL whom has put out their real identity since the start.
Yeah, they just forgot to mention that they were scam convicts.
Seriously, I get the impression that you simply want to believe and you refuse to accept any argument or evidence.