I'm an experienced and trusted seller, I have been running Coindaddy since 2013 but now I've re-launched the website with a new domain, new design and new Currencies.
Posting references would be a huge help, especially since there are a few red flags keeping people away:
New account
New domain
No SSL
Hosted on wix.com (?)
There is another site using the coindaddy name: coindaddy.io
Don't take this the wrong way. Think of it has me trying to help you since most are gonna be very skeptical.
EDIT:
You might also want to remove the paypal partner logo from the bottom of your site
