Post
Topic
Board Economics
Re: Inflation, Fractional Reserve, and Bitcoins
by
chretienm
on 01/06/2011, 11:50:01 UTC
I've seen a few claims, on these forums and elsewhere, that bitcoins, because they are limited in supply, are free from inflation, and once or twice I've seen claims that this set supply would eliminate fractional reserve bank policies.  Would anyone care to explain this to me? 

The way I see it, the supply of bitcoins is limited, yes, but its akin to the supply of, in the US, physical one-dollar bills.  The majority of the US economy, however, is not cash - it is credit, or dollars on account, both of which are backed essentially by loan collateral.  This collateral forms the basis for more loans than it is actually worth, and thus we have fractional reserve banking.  The limited supply of bitcoins will stand at 21,000,000 maximum.  However, this in no way prevents people from establishing accounts with bitcoin-equivalent units in them that do not actually exist - exactly as credit and savings accounts are done today.  These pseudo-BTC would be traded, just as loan-based pseudo-dollars are traded today, and there is no limit to their number, nor any protection against fractional reserve policies.  Am I going wrong here somewhere?  I certainly hope so, because if not....then I really don't see the advantage of BTC at all.
Sir you are correct in some ways in that the US dollars are over represented in our present fractional reserve banking in that the banks loan out much more than they have and have collateral (hopefully real and valuable collateral not collapsing housing priced collateral) but with bitcoin you can avoid all that by only dealing with real bitcoins. Accept nothing that is supposedly backed by bitcoins only deal with actual bitcoins and then you will not be taking part in a fractional reserve type system because those systems always fail especially if not backed by gold.