...
1. It's not really up to what you think. It's Lutpin's negative rating because Lutpin got ripped off.
...
He has just expressed his opinion (just like you did just now) because that's what this thread is for. If Lutpin wasn't interested in community's judgement, he would've just left trust feedback without starting this thread (or locked it).
...
2. If I walked into your house and stole from you, you called me out on it and I gave it back, do you now trust me?
Comparing stealing physical goods with IP rights infringement sounds retarded 99% of the time. But I'll play along:
You stole something, got called on it, gave it back, apologised, promised not to do it anymore. Should you be jailed for the rest of your life, or should you be given a chance to compensate for your wrongdoing? If the latter, what (in your opinion) should Girlbtc.com do to have the negative removed?