Interesting initiative, can't wait to see what impact will it have.
But what's the end result you're trying to achieve? Is it to create one main list ("general"?) to serve as a single point of reference for other campaign managers to use when considering applications? Or do you want maintain 3 separate lists + 'general' and 'Permanently Blacklisted' just as informative additions?
In theory it doesn't matter, you could say that each manager can choose whichever list(s) he prefers (if any), but imo, putting focus on one, main list (by clearly denoting it as 'main' and possibly moving other, supportive lists to 2nd post) will have much stronger effect, especially if you intend to take more managers on-board.
Are the lists on the first two posts the definitive SMAS blacklists? Is there a place where I can just retrieve a text file with just the names of all of the people on the SMAS blacklist? I am planning on including an SMAS blacklist indicator for my account pricer.
Will it only be an indication, or will you adjust the value of such account accordingly?