The aim of the blacklist is to identify the spammers on the forum and stop them from being enrolled into most of the signature campaigns on the forum right?
The blacklist is primarily aimed at helping our own campaigns, of which there are plenty ATM. Adding independent reviewing and other stuff that SMAS previously had will complicate things and probably make it *dead* again. From the previous (updated) post:
As a manager, you work on behalf the advertiser and have the right to deny service to anyone. If you want to use this list you either:
1) Trust our judgement and go with it.
2) Review members that you come across (from the blacklist) yourself.
If you guys are working for your lists to be adopted by everyone (you seem to be going for this) then i dont think its smart for a small group of like minded individuals to act as judge, jury and executioner. Just my 2 cents tho, good luck on your project