Why do you have a bunch of pictures with peoples name listed and then have privacy on the domain paytaler.com? Doesn't make any sense that you would show identities and then have privacy on the domain name. What about that?
Just read this part "we decided to eschew traditional escrow arrangements."
So in other words you are not using escrow. So no escrow, a website with privacy on the domain, and pictures of a bunch of Russians. What could go wrong?