This pool hasn't had amonth above 100% since june and october., and may barely made it in there. It's hard to keep people around when the stats don't lie and things haven't been good here for awhile.
Kano always says it's a numbers game, but since the halving, this pool has been struggling for some reason.
Which sucks.
Yeah I've spent (as I do each time I process a payout, but today a lot more) time going through the numbers.
The current monthly stats are actually all even from May to the end of November, excluding the last block of November.
This bad run of luck began with that last block in November and as we all know has continued.
So while, indeed this month so far has been very bad, the total since May excluding this current run of bad luck is above 100%.
So, no I can't agree at all with your analysis of the data

Here's the table from the stats page, I edited November, only removing the last block of November.
Month Got Expected
2016 Nov 69 69.78 (I removed the last block of November)
2016 Oct 82 79.69
2016 Sep 110 113.72
2016 Aug 126 134.02
2016 Jul 126 127.32
2016 Jun 132 119.14
2016 May 126 125.37
Total blocks: 771
Expected blocks: 769.04
= Luck: 100.25%
Again, yes we have had a very bad run of luck since the last block of November, but that's basically it.