You're missing the one ATH that silences them all: Gox.
no one with any analytical should take the gox price seriously for anything other than sentimental reasons. that price was created because you couldn't your dollars out. that means it wasn't a functional exchange even when it was alive.
Just for shit and giggles, we should too add in the Mt Gox all time high. What was that again? I forgot, I think it was around $1250, I dont know the exact number.
At this rate, we will surpass that too, we are about to hit $1200 in Bitfinex, we saw $1197.