Perhaps you should have waited to rate the ICO until you actually understood the basics of the ICO. It was obvious that you did not read the Russian whitepaper or have a basic understanding of what is being developed prior to your review. Now that Sergey has taken time out of his schedule to interview and answer all your questions, we should expect an actual accurate review score in my opinion.
After reviewing other projects on your list, I have to say I have some serious doubts about how you come to your conclusions. I am also interested in your track record to scoring ICOs. Did ones you scored high in the past actually perform well or provide results?
We need to do better as a community to do our jobs WELL. If that means owning a review site, then you should do your reviews WELL before publishing. You owe that to all people in the crypto space.
Since in the review my opinion was voiced, I will answer in the first-person.
I understand your call for responsibility for the published reviews, but I'm inclined to believe that my investment experience gives me the right to express my opinion about any project, including through the created site. The usefulness of these reviews will determine the community. As main result we already have - recorded interview with lead of project. By the way. After this intrview my opinion has not undergone a fundamental change... maybe it's happen in april 2017.
About other projects please read this page
https://icotracker.net/aboutI understand where you're coming from, but I think there is some merit to Jon's argument. It did seem you published a review of MobileGo without any real basis of what was going on. Perhaps you really do have great reasoning for the score you gave, but without providing reasons why it could be entirely based on opinion. I think we can both see a problem with that. You can't really dish out scores to projects without giving your detailed reasoning. Maybe now you're a bit annoyed with Jon because of his comments, so you're biased and just give the project bad marks. Without defining your individual process for each project, you don't give your website integrity, and you don't help projects improve/defend themselves.