It was pure rhetoric though which is something that could hardly ever be referred to as "brilliant". Satoshi was brilliant, but you see its because he proposed an actual solution, he wasn't just arguing semantics versus an already existing solution.

It's not actually amazing if you think about it from a perspective of macro-economic theory.  It actually makes sense why bitcoin is valuable which has nothing at all to do with the transaction capacity.


No one is going to read or address a bunch of rambling, at least compress your argument. And I traversed it, its not founded, do you claim your argument is scientifically founded, because I don't think you do.