SegWit can revitalize Bitcoin while Bitcoin Unlimited can only create another wall between users.
You don't believe it? Just check up what is happening to Litecoin, they are on a brink of SegWit's activation.
The price of LTC is soaring, media attention is higher than ever and community is positively thrilled.
http://litecoinblockhalf.com/segwit.php Litecoin is only ~6% away from a major breakthrough.
I already said what I'm about to say in another thread, but the fact is you aren't wrong.
I would prefer to see more devs come out with their own systems and concepts for solving the blocksize issue, and we can see if there's something of value that can be used and added, but right now Segwit is looking like a pretty good solution for the entire debate. Now it comes down to how much the community will consider it.