I can get to that page, and I have both copy's of my private key. I used the compressed key in the transaction where I sent my BTC to the compressed address. I have all the pieces just don't know how to use them. The original wallet the funds came out of is a free wallet from blockchain. So what I think you're telling me is that if I open that wallet and use my non compressed key where it asks for the address I'm transferring funds from, then it will go back in my wallet? Or should I use the key I originally used? Why are there two of everything anyway, to make it more frusterating? (Jk)
I really don't understand what kind of wallet you are talking about but I'm guessing it's blockchain.info. I don't know how it works but I found this post:
Settings -> Addresses -> Manage Address at imported addresses -> Import Address -> put the private key in the box -> Import -> Close
So do that if you want to use blockchain.info. If you don't (which I recommend) use Electrum and when you start it for the first time choose "Restore a wallet or import keys" there just put your private key and enjoy having full control of your coins unlike in blockchain.info because as far as I researched it doesn't give you the option to export your private keys.