Yea you posted a 2 instead of a 1. I can confirm that signature is legit! 
I still can't see where it was screwed up, lol.
WRONG:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
2017-01-16 controlled by ryanc
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
144187999121393192DxViqQKPPrghj9M3
H1t3t0ZE+/QayD0S7/2RfMUvz9Qsh/9cFW8obuc4K3VDTkTJF+30ZRcW97TrdW3iNfEonx8BfqiSrfYAcYIIeDU=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
CORRECT:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
2017-01-26 controlled by ryanc
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
144187999121393192DxViqQKPPrghj9M3
H1t3t0ZE+/QayD0S7/2RfMUvz9Qsh/9cFW8obuc4K3VDTkTJF+30ZRcW97TrdW3iNfEonx8BfqiSrfYAcYIIeDU=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----