Post
Topic
Board Announcements (Altcoins)
Re: [ANN][LSK] Lisk | Blockchain Application Platform for JavaScript Developers
by
Reavon
on 25/04/2017, 13:59:19 UTC
I really like the Lisk project but this "101 nodes forging" system has become one big corrupt fuck-up.

I will never vote again, ever.

Yeah well, currently it's like this. Once SDK is done we will start voting for some real projects, I would say time is needed for evolution.

Right now I'm running a Waves Node, you can just run it as long as you hold over 10k of Waves.
No voting involved.
If you don't want to run a node, you can lease your Waves to a node and still receive fees and "miner reward tokens".

Lisk is not doing much for Lisk holders.
Just by holding Waves, I got several free tokens that can be traded for real money.

Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge fan of both Lisk and Waves, but this is where Lisk really screwed up.
The Waves team understands how to please their investors.

But still, I think Lisk will be great in Q4 2017.



yes there is some discussion on github about improving lisk dpos:
https://github.com/LiskHQ/lisk/issues/353

I proposed my idea
It could be great to see more comments there from this community.




Nice attempt but here is what i think could become problematic with your idea.

1. a ranking in finding a block the higher you are to the 1st rank add very much to centralization because the top 50 could than maybe easyly 51% attack the rest. There is a reason we have 101 delegates who more or less mine the same amount of block  so there is alway a consensus, because in contrast of PoW Dpos has not much incentive for the nodes other than satisfy their voters.

2. the client is optimized to 101 nodes , increasing the amount of nodes would require rebalancing the code processing and much more under the hood it simply is not PoW work which can scale naturely with more nodes. Its is a very different approach with is strenghts and weaknesses.


I believe we will see lisk creating a very nice groundwork for developers to create a new internet of Apps on lisk and later on maybe in 3-4 we will see a major core tech upgrade that will revolutionize they way Bapps work in a similar manner dash and monero did for anon tx.