Post
Topic
Board Economics
Re: Nobody Can Have Benefit From a Big Pump
by
deisik
on 02/05/2017, 08:29:58 UTC
If Bitcoin price pumps from $1300 to $3000 in few hours, nobody would make profit from it, because the exchanges wouldn't allow you to sell your Bitcoins and make the fast profit, it would bring a big loss for exchange sites.

Do you agree with this?

If exchange itself is not trading, they basically don't care

More specifically, they care for fees, and trading fees obviously come from trades, so when there are abrupt price movements the trading volume spikes too. And it doesn't matter whether the price flash crashes or flash surges. So, they are in fact interested in volatility and price being "alive", therefore prices pumping to 3,000 dollars per coin would provide exactly that, i.e. insane levels of volatility

This is actually right. Exchamgr are having profit from transaction fee and they are not the one who buy and sell the coin you are trading. The devs of the coin is the one who is giving funds for the exchange to cover some buy/sell order and the majority of the order on exchange came from different traders too. So having a flash punp is not an issue for exchangr

I don't think that exchanges are having anything from transaction fees

You seem to be confusing them with miners. Nevertheless, there are ways which are allow exchanges to earn money off their clients and these have nothing to do with fees. The most conspicuous example is front-running the orders of the clients. Many exchanges have set up deliberate delays under various names. For example, at Btc-e all trading data is cashed every 2 seconds, but this in effect means that you can't find out what happens to your order within this interval after you send it. So the exchange has 2 seconds within which they may not actually place the order at once but wait and see if there is another offsetting order coming in. If the spread of these two orders is negative, the exchange itself can fill both of them and book the spread as profit. They don't even need any funds for that since they are just writing down the spread in their favor