Questioning whether a technical solution has been implemented in the best manner is not the same as attempting to smear it.
I have not claimed that you have attempted to smear it. I said that you could do it if you wanted to. Moving on, based on what are you questioning this? The super majority of developers and experts stating that Segwit is very good? Maybe lay off the r/btc & BU "scientists" kool-aid.[1] 
[1] - This is not meant to be offensive, but rather friendly advice for the health of your brain.