Let's say that Bitcoin takes the place of the USD within 10 years and see what the energy consumption of the bitcoin network will be.
facts:
- USD "M2" money supply in 2009: 8E12 USD (
http://money.howstuffworks.com/how-much-money-is-in-the-world.htm)
- in 2023 there will be 19E6 BTC. Mining will be honoured with 6.25 BTC/10min => 329'000 BTC/y (
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Controlled_supply)
assumptions:
- BTC takes the place of USD => one BTC will be worth 421'053$ (of course valuation of BTC will devaluate USD...but let's leave that aside.)
- let's say 1kWh costs 10cts USD
- all miners use the same recent technology. Or at least with equal efficiency in MH/J
- people are not paying significant transaction fees by 2023 (the more people will pay fees, the higher the resulting profitable global energy consumption)
(edit) In a free market the following formula approximates energy consumption of any PoW based cryptocurrency:
GlobalEnergyConsumptionForMining ~= (MiningReward + TransactionFees) * bitcoinValueInUSD / EnergyCostInUSDperkWhSo mining would be profitable somewhere below an energy consumption of the bitcoin network of:
break even price: 421'053$/BTC*329'000BTC/y = 139E9$/y
equivalent energy: 1.39E12 kWh/y
Today's global electricity consumption is around 20E12 kWh/y (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_energy_consumption)
This means that the bitcoin network by itself would raise global electricity consumption by up to 7%Please show me where I'm wrong!
We could of course put this less dramatic:
- in 2033 it would be 174E9 kWh/y
- in 2100 it would be 2.65 GWh/y
today we would be at 5MWh if all miners were using newest ASIC's (
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Mining_hardware_comparison)
(edit)CONCLUSIONS:
- according to economical basics, energy consumption of the bitcoin network does not depend on mining gear efficiency!
- the problem described applies to every proof-of-work based currency (including Litecoin) because proof-of-work equals proof-of-energy-consumption at a market equilibrium
- bitcoin value is NOT directly backed by energy consumption. But mining rewards and transaction fees are.
- the slower the bitcoin value rises and the lower the transaction fees, the lower the energy consumption of the bitcoin network on the long run