Yea, that is possible if you have multiple inputs which increases the size of the transaction. And the bigger the transaction is more fee you will have to pay.

I used Paypal recently to transfer about $21.46, it cost me $1.89 then I end up with $19.57... And I transferred that $19.57 to my bank account without paying extra fees.

With Bitcoin, fee is very expensive now, and you have to pay it whenever you "think" about making a transaction.