Your poll is way too unbalanced. I'd chose no, but not for the stated reason.
I've had no issues with him and I was in a signature campaign he managed not that long ago.
I have no reasons to not trust him. But that doesn't mean I trust him blindly, I'd never trust blindly anyone.
Also I don't understand your problem. This should be Theymos' problem. If he trusts OgNasty, what's your problem with that?
TL;DR; No, he should not be removed by user request; it's Theymos' pure decision.
good point - i will add an additional no box. But can I ask why you wouldn't prefer people to use a multisig escrow?
This is not about technology and not much about OgNasty either; it's about people minding their own business.
If you would be at least donor, you should discuss this issue (if it's really an issue) with Theymos. It's 100% up to him.
TL;DR:
The answer is already in my post: it's Theymos' decision and I respect that. Just as simple.