Is it possible to use 2 Power Supplies?
Yes but I wouldn't go lower than a 750watt as that will be at its safety limit IMO. Remember 110 VAC power supplies are most efficient roughly anywhere from 50%-80% depending on the rating (bronze/gold/platinum). If it was a server power supply you could push those harder. Just plug the each board to one power supply only.
There is the server power supply route and breakout board which would be a overall cost savings.