Not a file sharing, but distributed DHT-like database HASH=BLOCK
This "DHT" call comes up frequently. This is fine for experiments, and as a backup method akin to the recent
blockchain-over-twitter project. But it is woefully less secure and resilient than the current scheme.
Bitcoin uses a "D1HT"... a fancy term for "everybody has a copy of the database." Currently the entire blockchain is massively replicated, perhaps 20,000+ times or more.
This is larger than all but the largest torrent swarms.Benefits: More secure and resilient. Far more decentralized. Better chance of useful work, if one honest peer is found. 100% provable for any node; no "holes" in the history. Costs: Network and disk resources required to store the blockchain, and provide it to others for download.
Going from that, a DHT is quite a step down, quite a bit less secure. DHTs are vulnerable to hot spots -- where the whole world queries just a few nodes -- and sybil attacks[1]. On
sybil attacks, bitcoin's current peer finding mechanism does a better job of intentionally spreading itself widely across networks; a DHT tends to concentrate on a few nodes.
It becomes much easier to attack
a portion of the blockchain, if it were stored as (hash,block) key-value pairs as commonly suggested. If an attacker may DoS even a single (hash,block) pair, you prevent the entire world from downloading or verifying the entire bitcoin blockchain, because the chain is thus broken. The time spent looking up each hash across a worldwide DHT would be quite slow; that is the equivalent of downloading 234,831 different torrents, not one big torrent.
Storage via DHT is a fun toy idea, but it's stupid, slow and insecure as a primary method. Massive replication is far more secure and decentralized.
Hard drive technology has no problems keeping up with blockchain growth. Network technology is probably the same, though I think there will be some amount of balancing on-chain versus off-chain transactions.
It is also thought that the nodes bearing the brunt of the blockchain downloads in the future will be a few professional and volunteer "archive nodes", that store the entire blockchain. And certainly the
blockchain torrent will continue to exist as an alternate method.
[1] Remains an active area of DHT research, and several mitigation mechanisms are deployed in the field. Even with these new techniques, the DoS-a-block, DoS-all-of-bitcoin implications make DHTs an inferior solution.