Most of the critics aginst EOS coin is relevant to 99% of the rest ico's. Lets check how long scam hyps last... well around 3-4 monts right?! So it is too early to decide.
Beside this the team looks serious, the conception regarding business is applyable, the technology behind seems promosing and they got the best code of several coins.
The last is, if you don't like it buy fitness brecelet like this you will know that there are 263 steps to pastry.
The thing is, it will be a 1-year wait AT LEAST to decide if EOS is a scam. We are talking about hundreds of days of ICO, raking in the money. The team is serious... so? Dogecoin team was not serious but it proved more viable than 90% of alts. The technology behind it? EOS is a proven clone of its dev's previous project with the codes only changing the name of the files (github).