I usually steer clear of such discussions but as I usually enjoy ShadowOfHarbringer's comments quite a bit, I'll just go ahead and risk "feeding the trolls (tm)";
I agree that I may have a troll-ish style of discussion (sorry for that) but I also do have valid arguments (of which
almost none was really adressed by JoelKatz).
It's OK, when you start asking hard questions JoelKatz starts ignoring you.