We won't pay out the money unless ordered by court or police.
Ha, that's funny. Reputable casinos have exact opposite policy

But as you mentioned court order, I took a look at your site:
This agreement is made and entered into by and between you and Fairlay LLC, incorporated in the Republic of Costa Rica under ID number 3-101-736435 of the National Registery
So I was planning on requesting the full company / personnel details to give betg a legal avenue to make his claim, but there are no such records of a company existing. I guess it's no surprise as there are no LLC's in Costa Rica. Just S.A. and S.R.L.'s.

There appears to be no problem with their site, as it is working for every other legitimately incorporated company that I have tried.