Would obviously hate to be scammed. What options do I have?
You clearly had the terms laid out to you when you opened the trade and you should have followed these terms and conditions. Unfortunately it'll really depend on how big a fuss the seller makes, if he's fine with it then he should have no problems with releasing the funds to you when the transaction clears.
If he refuses to do that, then your option is to dispute the transaction.
Try to reason with the support to reach a fair deal.