i recieved my ats but a little bit late due to the fact that authorship faced many issues regarding on thier refferal ip system thats why people are alarming and called ats a scam but they are not really a scam and infact they paid me and many other users here. maybe the ones who dont recieve the ats token are just cheating and registered more than once using the same ip and referal links.
I can't deny that there are honest ones that didn't received their ATS. Even some of my referrals.
And their frustrations are understandable.