Post
Topic
Board Development & Technical Discussion
Re: Confused about 2x and the 1:1 coin ownership after fork
by
monkeydominicorobin
on 26/10/2017, 09:07:25 UTC
Im sorry as im sure this is answered but the more I read, the more confused I get with terms about splitting and replay tx's etc.

Can somebody help me understand the specific point of holding 1 btc and then having 1 btc and 1 btc2x after fork?

I understand that if I have 1 btc now and hold private key cold storage and dont transact for a few days around fork time.

But what I dont get is where the 1 btc2x is generated from?  Its not a new coin so its not pre-mined, right?

Is it basically down to me choosing to spend either the 1 btc or the 1 btc2x but not having ability to spend both of them?  This would seem to explain alot of the holes I think i have in my understanding.

After the fork, dont they have to become two seperate chains moving forward thus becoming a new altcoin?  Or am I missing something here that somehow wont turn btc2x and btc into 2 chains with 2 coin types after the fork happens?  Miners will be generating rewards on two chains causing generation of new coins on a new chain so i dont see how it would not be an altcoin after the fork occurs.

Is there a huge money risk here for a long-term btc holder that doesnt intend to stop holding?  I think the answer is no, not any more than usual volatile/high-risk of cryptocurrency.  Am I correct that I dont need to make a decision on my favored fork if Im just a long-term holder?  If some of my above understanding is right about the 1:1 coin holding then i think I simply would hold all my btc / btc2x and in 20 years, i could cashout one or the other from my 1 coin example (but not both).  Theres no decision timeline I need to worry about, right?

I understand that you want more coins. But at least you should pick a side. The fork will help you earn another coin. But I would advise against acquiring coins of those who want to destroy Bitcoin. Bitcointalk is always posting the newest version of the Bitcoin client. Once Bitcoin cash and Bitcoin Gold succeeds. No one will be inclined to develop a newer version of the Bitcoin client. And bitcointalk has nothing to post when it comes new clients because it will cease to exist. FYI Bitcoin cash and Bitcoin Gold is about creating a new paypal which is notorious for freezing accounts. We don't want that to happen to Bitcoin Classic/Core.