Instead of using shameless self promotion, I'd like to speak directly to the owners of faucet lists or faucet rotators. Feel free to insert my faucetes in your lists/rotators, I could use more traffic and currently I'm seeing very few referrals among the claims.

And now for the OP, I'll be reintroducing my own faucet list in the coming week and I'll most likely figure out some way to rank the faucets. Most likely it'll have a feature so that you can submit your faucet favorites on the page as well. It's still a week or so out though. I have the code running smoothly but I still need to figure out the best way to sort the faucets and make a decent presentation. At some point in the coming weeks, I'll probably reintroduce my mining site as well. (Browser miner that pays in any of the crypto-currencies supported by Faucethub.io, code is operational but it needs a pretty face.)

As a general rule of thumb I'd suggest starting with Faucethub's own faucet list, and work your way down the list. Don't limit yourself to only claiming from the first page faucets, take your time and work your way down the list. A lot of the time you'll find the gems farther down the list. Many smaller faucets will offer better rewards to attract new traffic. And don't get too stuck in old habits, faucets are updated and changes frequently (I know I'm tweaking my own faucets daily). Just because a faucet didn't appeal to you a week or two ago, it doesn't mean that you won't like it today. Faucet updates can turn a weak faucet into a great one... So, go through the list on regular intervals to see if there are any interesting changes/updates.