I finally did get a confirmation. It took less than 10 minutes...

I tried a different computer, that didn't solve it.

I think what it was is switching the Curl Implementation. Apparently Webgl 2 uses the graphics card but may not work on some computers, or so I gather.

I switched to CCurl. Hitting Save and then attempting to reattach was not enough, it still wouldn't confirm...

For anyone having the same problem, I think it may be necessary to switch to CCurl, then Save, then close and restart the wallet and start the Recovery Tool process over again.

I now have a hash that shows Status Confirmed on the tangle explorer iotasear.ch/hash

Hopefully this helps anyone with the same issue.