Is it me or does something feel "off" about all this???
Its not only you, its 99% of the community that has the same feeling about this :p
I'm totally new to this space but my thoughts are:
Bitcoin gold isn't a beautifully polished presentation with a glossy website. People expect to see this as the de facto nowadays. Without the glossy marketing people think that it must be a scam. Often the best restaurants are mom and pop joints - maybe don't have the best location like McDonalds but they do have the best food. Don't judge a book by it's cover, all that shines is not gold etc..etc
However, one thing for sure is that all most successful scams - banking system, Clinton, pyramid selling always have the best looking brochures! Maybe these guys are just trying to do something good and really are not into wasting their efforts on advertising.